4 Reasons Healing Meters Suck

4 Reasons Healing Meters Suck

Thumbs Down (with Clipping Path)

This is a guest post by Ulkesshern, an EU Holy Paladin from Hellfire

Matticus put a plea out for guest posts and despite it been something I’ve never done I figured ‘Hey, why not?’ and offered up my services and here I am! I’m a Holy Paladin from the EU realm of Hellfire and I’m currently enjoying the delights of the 25 man content.

For my inaugural post I’ve decided to focus on one of my major bug bears, the absolutely terrible creations that are healing meters and the issues I perceive with them.

Issue 1: More Healing does not equal Better Healers

Without trying to oversimplify the job of DPS their job is basically to do damage, the more damage they do the (arguably) better they are, boss health is constant so the more damage they do the quicker the boss dies, the quicker people get their loot and the quicker you progress. However that really isn’t the case for healers. Picture this scenario, you’ve all just hit 80, you’re all predominantly in your old Tier 6 or quest rewards and you head to Naxx.

People are going to be taking massive amounts of damage, Tank mitigation will be low, DPS will be low so the encounters will be lasting longer and as such you’re going to be healing your heart out. Fast forward to the point when you go back with everyone in shiny Level 80 epics. The tanks don’t lose as much health every hit, encounters last half the amount of time and you’re not going to be breaking a sweat.

Then out come the meters!

“Oh wow my DPS is almost double what it was when we started here” cries StabbyStabster your top Rogue.
“Yeah mine too, we’re awesome now” join in the rest of the DPS.

Then someone links the healing comparison.

Well look at that, you’ve healed probably half of what you healed last time and instantly the people who don’t get it start moaning at you for not pulling your weight. The thing is we scale almost inversely with the raids gear level, but in the minds of so many people bigger numbers equals better players.

Issue 2: Situational Situations are Situational

This is something that an amazing amount of people just fail to understand, who you are assigned to heal can greatly affect your position on the meters, and I saw a wonderful example of this in a raid I was in last night. We were twenty manning Patchwerk for the achievement (yes I like achievements). Our tanks were a Death Knight, a Druid and a Warrior and our healing team comprised of 3 Paladins, a Priest and Shaman. The Paladins were assigned one Tank each while beaconing a different Tank, so all 3 Tanks had one Paladin and were the recipient of one Beacon, while the Priest and Shaman were assigned to just go crazy on all of the tanks.

We killed him pretty easily and were impressed with ourselves, and then someone linked the healing meter, Two Paladins at the top, followed by the Priest and then the Druid. Languishing at the bottom was the Third Paladin.

At first glance, it seemed that the Paladin was failed as his healing done was absolutely terrible. However when you thought about it, there were reasons.

Firstly, he was topping the over healing meters by a large margin. Then realization sets in, he was healing the main Tank, not the hateful strike soaks, and as such there was a lot less damage to heal and because Beacon of Light only transfers effective healing (of which there was very little). Whereas the other Paladins were hitting with ~14k effective heals and getting them beaconed across for about the same, the “bottom Paladins” heals weren’t needed as much and as such weren’t getting beaconed either.

3 Paladins, 3 Targets, 3 Players spamming the same heals with very different results. To some people that means that one of them was failing, a scenario that had entered no ones mind until the meters were linked. Just seconds earlier everyone was congratulating the Healers on such a good job!

At the end of the day, no one died except the boss and it was a good clean kill, only once the meters were show did any doubt suddenly arise as to the performance of healers.

Issue 3: Some Classes outclass Classes

A sad but true truth is that some classes usually end up beating others, Paladins can’t HoT or multi target as well (if at all) as Priests, Shaman, Druids and a lot of players just can’t understand that.

I once had a Guild Master state that “All of our healers are fantastic except our Paladins”. His reasoning? The other healers always beat the Paladins on meters (Late TBC Content). We tried to explain that no one ever died so we were doing our job but it just didn’t cut it, as far as he was concerned, the other classes were topping the meters so they were better and the Paladins were failing. We weren’t failing; he just couldn’t get his head around the different class mechanics and intended roles of the healing classes. Amusingly all the Paladins left soon after.

I daren’t even poke the sleeping bear that is absorption/mitigation effects. I feel for you Discipline Priests, I really do!

Issue 4: Meters are not infallible

Nothing and nobody is perfect (even me!) and meters are no exception, I’ve seen five people link meters from the same fight that have shown completely different results. I’ve seen WWS reports where I apparently wasn’t even there! I’ve spoken to Paladins who make a deal with a Warlock to keep them beaconed and instruct them to life tap like crazy. I’ve played with Priests who did nothing but spam Circle of Healing relentlessly and Shaman who may have just had a keyboard with one button marked Chain Heal. I’ve seen people of all spec that completely ignore whatever healing assignments they have in order to just spam quick heals on someone the second they take damage, I once had a Warlock point out that they really didn’t need 9 separate people to heal him the second he life tapped. I’ve even known people just type random numbers into raid chat and try and pass them off as a meter!

Final Thoughts

Meters do have a place, they’re amazingly useful for DPS, they also do serve a purpose for Healers, but they sure as anything aren’t something you can just glance at quickly and pick out who is top. If no one in the raid is dying our job is getting done and getting done well. If people are dropping like flies then perhaps consult some meters, look at what’s happening though, don’t just assume that the person on the bottom is there because he is terrible!

I’ve had meters running since Kara and I think I’ve looked at them perhaps once, coming top on a little chart doesn’t make you the worlds greatest Healer, doing your job and keeping people alive no matter how much or how little healing it requires makes you a good Healer.

(And no I don’t live at the bottom of meters!)

About Matticus

Matticus is the founder of World of Matticus and Plus Heal. Read more of his columns at WoW Insider. League of Legends player. Caffeine enthusiast.



  1. [...] about Phaelia’s guest blogger earlier today), and he’s got a great post up too, about healing meters and why they just aren’t helpful to anyone. Damage meters are well known to be disliked by many players — while they can often [...]

  2. [...] temporary blogger early today), and he’s got a enthusiastic place up too, most healing meters and ground they meet aren’t helpful to anyone. Damage meters are substantially famous to be dislikable by whatever players — [...]

  3. [...] about Phaelia’s guest blogger earlier today), and he’s got a great post up too, about healing meters and why they just aren’t helpful to anyone. Damage meters are well known to be disliked by many players — while they can often [...]

  4. [...] about Phaelia’s guest blogger earlier today), and he’s got a great post up too, about healing meters and why they just aren’t helpful to anyone. Damage meters are well known to be disliked by many players — while they can often [...]

  5. [...] about Phaelia’s guest blogger earlier today), and he’s got a great post up too, about healing meters and why they just aren’t helpful to anyone. Damage meters are well known to be disliked by many players — while they can often [...]

  6. [...] meters don’t even begin to tell you how a healer is performing. (For more on this visit World of Matticus and be sure to read the comments!) If they seem to be off their game don’t make an issue [...]

  7. [...] To the previous 2 posters: this isn’t really possible because the combat log doesn’t tell you which spell caused damage absorption, and therefore who cast it (according to Recount’s current author). Besides, depending on luck/gear/skill, it’s highly random. Example: you did your job, but your tank avoided most hits, resulting in your shields not absorbing a whole hell of a lot. Does that make you a bad healer ? No. But a meter wouldn’t show much. Shields are preventive "heals", traditional heals are reactive. Important difference. The best way is to educate your group leaders as to your abilities and teach them how to use a Healing Meter. It’s not as simple as a Damage Meter. Also, give this a read: 4 Reasons Healing Meters Suck : World of Matticus [...]

  8. [...] Goblin, certainly knows how to push a point, often directly at odds with many an old, wizened head1. But he’s essentially right, in a very limited [...]

  9. [...] 14, 2009 by khaeli While many healers agree that healing meters are a poor judge of a healer's performance, there needs to be some way to assess whether or not a healer is doing his or her job well, and [...]

  10. [...] However, it’s not always possible to simply ignore people who place too much reliance on meters. It isn’t uncommon for raid leaders in PuGs to use meters as the sole determinant of a player’s worth to the raid. While meters can sometimes point out glaring problems, it is absolutely rage-inducing to watch someone boil down a player’s ability to a simple number, without regard for fight mechanics favoring certain classes, whether a player was doing a special job, or any other number of circumstances. When healing meters are brought up, I usually enter a state of uncontrollable anger that leaves me unable to speak (and sometimes foaming at the mouth). Comparing healers by their healing numbers is absolute garbage, for reasons best explained by World of Matticus. [...]

  11. [...] This is a guest post from Derevka who has been actively blogging on his blog Tales of a Priest. This post is in reply to Healing Meters Suck and tries to tie in some qualitative and quantitative healing performance analysis. [...]

  12. [...] 4 Reasons Healing Meter Sucks – Ulkesshern guest posts with his thoughts on the flaws of healing meters. [...]